Category: Custom Cookies

download (18)



Cookies are a timeless treat that can be enjoyed by anyone. If you’re looking for a cookie that is not only delicious but also handmade, then look no further than The Black and White Cookie Company. The Black and White Cookie Company brings the personal touch to classic black and white cookie baking without the hassle. Although there’s nothing like the taste of homemade goods, not everyone has the time to dedicate to baking. When you order from The Black and White Cookie Company, you make the great decision of buying preservative-free treats.

One of the benefits of making baked goods yourself is that you know exactly what is in them. Thanks to the open nature of The Black and White Cookie Company, you can rest assured you’re not sacrificing this right. Finally, you can order genuinely crafted sweets–guilt free! If you want the best possible dessert in New York, then read on to find out why ordering black and white cookies online is the smart decision for you.

Choose a Time That’s Right for You

Some companies are not open on weekends or during late hours. However, sometimes these are the only times that you may be free. Between work, taking kids to and from events, and simply needing time to relax, making a trip to the store might end up on the bottom of your to-do list. With online ordering, you can place your order anytime you wish so long as you have a connection to the internet.

Custom Orders

Ordering online allows you to customize your cookie order ahead of time and ensure its perfection. The Black and White Cookie Company offers choices to suit your wedding, birthday, or graduation needs—and more! If you don’t have time to talk to the company on the phone, don’t fret. You can email with The Black and White Cookie Company at your convenience to begin creating your unique order. This company understands the value of online communication and will do their absolute best to make sure your needs are met.

Online Orders Are Convenient 

When you have to make baked goods yourself at home, you have to schedule your entire day around the event. Don’t let something that should be a treat become a roadblock in your day. Ordering cookies online lets you go about your business while the dedicated folks at The Black and White Cookie Company personally craft your order.

Save Time and Money

When you save yourself the physical trip to the bakery, you’re saving money on gas or cab fare. You also don’t have to worry about standing in line to place your order. Opt for the more stress-free and fanatically savvy option of ordering online for cost efficiency and to maximize your time.

The Black and White Cookie Company is a company that wants you to have the best experience possible. That’s why they have the innovative option of ordering online. You can save time, money, and stress by kicking back in your chair and taking care of your order when it’s most convenient for you. If you want to enjoy delicious cookies and still not have to leave the house, then don’t hesitate to make The Black and White Cookie Company your family’s choice of bakery.


Valentine’s Day was initially considered a day for lover’s to mate. A brief look into the day’s history suggests that Roman Paganism and the Catholic Church had something to do with its origin.

The earliest origins of Valentine’s Day suggest that it was associated with Lupercal’s feast during the 4th century BC. This pagan festival celebrated nature. It was held to honor Juno, the queen of Roman gods & goddesses. She was the goddess of marriage and women too and honoring her was considered a fertility rite. This celebration included a lottery where teenage girls’ names were drawn from a box. This was followed by an arbitrary matching with men for the remainder of the year.

But it is the Christian priest St. Valentine who holds the honor of having the most well-known legend. Legend has it that the then Emperor, Claudius II, had outlawed the marriage of young men since he believed it would make them better soldiers. Valentine fought this injustice and continued marrying young lovers. He was exiled in 270 AD as a result of this. Official records show that Feb. 14th was declared an official holiday for the church in memory of St. Valentine. This was till 1969 when Pope Paul VI took it off the calendar of the church.

Looking into this in great depth will reveal that the spread of Valentine’s Day throughout the world is proportional with the replacement of Paganism with Christianity. So this might just have been the Church’s way to Christianize the celebrations of Lupercal’s feast. And the only appropriate choice at the time probably was Valentine.

This concept probably only made it to North America during the 19th century when British settlers made their way here. Even though Valentine’s tale is ambiguous at best, they do highlight him as a heroic and romantic figure.

Apart from the U.S., Valentine’s Day is currently celebrated in France, Australia, the United Kingdom, Mexico, and Canada as well. With remarkable improvements in printing technology during the 19th century, small tokens of appreciation were replaced by printed cards as a way for people to express their emotions towards another. The direct expression of one person’s feelings towards another was discouraged at this time. The popularity of sending cards also increased when postage became cheaper. Today, more than 1 billion cards are exchanged on Valentine’s Day and women account for 85% of these purchases.

What are your plans for Valentine’s Day? Don’t have any? That just won’t cut it. Plan a romantic day for that special someone in your life. Even if you can’t come up with something unique, the simple dinner and a movie works quite well too, and don’t forget the black and white cookies.


There are several thousand cookie companies spread across the globe. So why should choose the Black and White Cookie Company over all the others? Well we are here to answer that. This cookie has a long-standing history that no other cookie company can compare to. Want to know more? Continue reading.

These Cookies Come in Custom Colors

Yes, it is true the traditional cookies from the Black and White Cookie Company are indeed black and white. However, these cookies can also be customized in almost any color you desire. This makes them perfect for special occasions such as holidays or weddings.

These Cookies are Perfect for Traditionalists

If you know someone who is strong on tradition, then the Black and White Cookie Company is the company for you. This company dates back over 100 years. They feature traditional black and white colors that will go perfectly with any party or style that you will need to host a traditional cookie for.

These Cookies are as Healthy as Cookies can Get

If you are part of the crowd that is trying to cut out preservatives, then don’t worry about adding these cookies to your diet. The Black and White Cookie Company bakes their cookies with all natural ingredients. They include no preservatives, no high fructose corn syrup, as well as 0 Trans fats. In addition, if you are required to eat Kosher then these are also the best cookies for you.

What Do the Cookies Taste Like?

What more reason do you need to order these cookies other than their amazing taste? Since these cookies come from a traditional background, they also feature the flavors from back in the day. The cookies brought to you by the Black and White Cookie Company feature a fluffy yellow cake like texture and flavor. They even give you a hint of lemon for a special flavor that you won’t get from your average cookie company. As if they could get any better these cookies are topped with a vanilla and chocolate fondant so that you get the best of both worlds when it comes to picking your favorite flavor fondant.

Do You Know a Seinfeld Fan?

We all know and love someone who is a fan of the show Seinfeld. However, did you know that these cookies were once featured on the show as well? It’s true, the cookies were used as a representation of how black and white shows get along in the same way they do on top of these cookies, and then all of our problems would be solved.

No matter what reason you choose to justify your Black and White cookie purchase it will be worth it. The people who make these cookies part of their tradition rave about how they taste perfect every time and how they melt in your mouth. If you think, you are ready to handle the greatness that comes from the Black and White Cookie Company then order your batch online today!

Tagged with: ,

If you’re looking for a tasty, unique gift, you’ve come to the right place. Our scrumptious Holiday-themed cookies and gift sets are sure to delight everyone on your list. They’ll love receiving a batch of their favorite Black and White Cookies iced in Chanukah or Christmas colors, and eating them even more!

One Dozen Chanukah-Themed Cookies

channukah_cookies_1024x1024A festival of delights. 12 yummy Chanukah-themed Black and White Cookies, with the same delicious vanilla and chocolate fondant, but colored Chanukah blue and white! Send this tasty batch to your family, friends, as a corporate gift, Chanukah gatherings or that real mentsh in your life! Platter not included. To order, click here.


One Dozen Christmas-Themed Cookies

rg_cookies_1024x1024A sweet gift for all 12 days of Christmas. 12 yummy Christmas-themed Black and White Cookies, with the same delicious vanilla and chocolate fondant, but colored red and green for Christmas! Perfect for your true love, a great friend, family or a Christmas party! To order, click here.


Mug & 6 Original Cookies

mug_6_cookies_1024x1024Everyone loves a cup of coffee with their Black and Whites, so we created the perfect gift set that includes six Original cookies and a stylish 16-oz coffee mug with our logo. Perfect for cozying up to a cookie and steaming cup of your favorite coffee. The mug has a wide brim for easy dunking and a large handle that makes it easy to hold your coffee in one hand while using the other to dunk and eat your cookie. To order, click here.

This gift set can also be ordered with Chanukah-themed or Christmas-themed cookies.

Cap & 6 Original Cookies

cap_6_cookies_1024x1024This gift set puts the smile in style, letting someone you love show the world they have great taste. Includes six Original cookies and a fashionable black baseball cap embroidered with our logo. To order, click here.

This gift set can also be ordered with Chanukah-themed or Christmas-themed cookies.

To see all of our gift sets, click here.

Don’t forget, ’tis the season for parties and we do custom orders for events. Add a scrumptious splash to your company Holiday party or any event! To place a custom order, click here.

Order by December 21 to ensure Holiday Delivery. Free USPS Priority Shipping to the continental United States on all orders.

Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

There are lots of imitations, but our cookies are the real thing. Handmade in Brooklyn, they have a delicious, old-fashioned bakery taste. You’ll wonder, “Is this a cake or a cookie? And, this sublime topping is… fondant?” You probably haven’t had fondant that didn’t come in a package. Real fondant…our fondant, is delicious and melts in your mouth. Sort of like a rich, glazed frosting. Our cookies, unlike store-bought imitations, are moist, spongy and stay that way, even in the refrigerator. You see, we’ve been at this a long time. Over a 100 years. The proof is in the cookie.

They’re even kosher with zero trans fat.

The Perfect Gift
Black and White cookies make a unique yummy, nostalgic gift that speaks of treasured family tradition. A gift from the Black & White Cookie Company not only delights the taste buds, but evokes sentimental memories for anyone on their birthday, holiday or special event. And bonus, your gift giving status will immediately go from ordinary to outstanding.

Customize Your Black and White Cookies for Special Events
We also offer customized cookies for events of any size. Mini or large, Black and White cookies in custom colors add a fun and striking visual to any buffet and are just as delicious. Pink or blue and white for a baby shower, match the color theme for a wedding, company party, birthday or bar mitzvah, get festive for the holidays. Break out the school colors for a class reunion, or the team colors for a sporting event or team party. The possibilities are endless and the result is always a fun, old fashioned delicious treat.